Straight-laced tax attorney Melissa Siren conceals a dark side. She yearns for a dominant man to force her to submit to his will. She enjoys a torrid love affair with young Aaron Devin, a blue-collar man ten years her junior. She finds in Aaron the perfect lover, exciting and dangerous, but never excessive. Melissa's taste for fine antiques leads to the purchase of a magical mirror capable of animating erotic lithographs and the seductive emotions they convey. As people around Melissa die violently, she encounters a dark soul from the other side of the mirror who tempts her with lavish gifts and beguiling promises. Melissa spurns young Aaron in favor of the charming stranger. Tensions build as Melissa's friends try to save her from Dante's Mirror.